A Classroom Library Makeover... for a Friend
I did a makeover on Mrs. Hiatt's first grade classroom library.

Mrs. Hiatt is a first grade teacher. My oldest daughter, Maille ("My-lee"), actually was in Mrs. Hiatt's class just last year, so I know how wonderful a teacher she is. And she and my wife, Megan, are good friends. Oh, and did I mention that Megan teaches in the room next door to Mrs. Hiatt? So Maille got to spend first grade with a first-rate teacher with Mommy right next door. It was a special year, to say the least.
The week before school started this year, I was helping Megan re-organize her library. The whole fam came along: there was Megan, re-labeling a stack of books; me, sifting through chapter books, deciding which series should be a category; Maille, who was given the job of sorting a pile of picture books into realistic fiction and fantasy (though very slowly because of getting caught up in reading every other book in its entirety); Adelyn (4), who was dragging a cart around the classroom, making pit stops to nab Arthur and Froggy books from our freshly made stacks; and Emerson (2), who was following Adelyn around the room, moving said Arthur and Froggy books to locations never to be found again.
Mrs. Hiatt popped her head in, and after chatting a bit, she asked if I'd be interested in overhauling her library. And that's the story behind the job.
Now let's get to her library.
The "Before"
The next day I met Mrs. Hiatt in her room and we talked about her library.
Interesting nuggets that surfaced from our conversation:
- Mrs. Hiatt has a lot of books.
- They were not organized: no categories, no labels.
- The lack of organization did not stress out Mrs. Hiatt. (She is go-with-the-flow in an awesome sort of way.)
- Mrs. Hiatt saw the advantages an organized classroom library would bring to her students.
- Mrs. Hiatt, in her classic go-with-the-flow style, gave me complete control.

So that's where I started. Mrs. Hiatt left me to it.
The "During"

I also began finding quite a few, shall we say, old books. Now I'm all for including classic stories, but I draw the line here:
As it turns out, some of these very old books were Mrs. Hiatt's husband's childhood books. Not joking! (Luckily, the one pictured above was not Mr. Hiatt's.) I love the sentimental value of these books and the personal connection that could be shared with students. But after my tongue-in-cheek suggestion for a "Vintage" category was turned down, most of these books were taken out, leaving more room for the more appealing books.

Here are the categories I ended up with:
- FICTION CATEGORIES: Realistic Fiction, Fantasy, Historical Fiction, Folktales & Fables, Mystery, Readers, Chapter Books, Picture Book Favorites, Series Favorites, Magic Tree House, Junie B. Jones
- NONFICTION CATEGORIES: Science, Social Studies, Animals, Joke Books, Math

The "After"
Putting Mrs. Hiatt's library back together was fun! Are you ready to see it?
The large bookcase that was crammed with books received some needed attention. I
reserved the top shelf for books that Mrs. Hiatt commonly uses in her
teaching, and the bottom shelf for over-sized books. With the middle
shelves, I de-cluttered a bit to make them more user-friendly, and added a little charm by turning some books horizontally, adding a couple of new, inexpensive baskets for a couple of her smaller categories, and placing some fun little knick-knacks that fit Mrs. Hiatt's nature theme.
The built-in bookshelves hold the main stock of books, using the plastic containers Mrs. Hiatt already had, with category labels laminated and held on with metal rings. I placed a new wicker basket on the floor that fits picture books perfectly (50% off at Hobby Lobby made it less than $10).
Next to a comfy chair, I placed a basket with some timely books, kind of like having the current magazine issues on your coffee table. Finally, I created a poster with simple library rules. I kept it in line with the nature theme and displayed in in a nice frame.
I went ahead and made a few versions of the classroom library poster for YOU! And as a bonus, there are coordinating bookmarks included! Click the image below to take you to the free download from my TeachersPayTeachers store.
![]() |
Click the image above to get the free posters. |
I hope you picked up a few insights into organizing a classroom library. If you'd like more information about classroom libraries, check out my 5-part series HERE. Thanks!